I'm down with Judis' argument for letting Michael Vick play. I think not giving him a second chance is only maximizing the immorality of his own actions. If society is better than him we'll show this talented player that we have more mercy then he showed his animals.
The bonus? When Vick gets his head knocked off Lawrence Taylor style from a blindside blitz we can debate over who gets to toss his carcass on an electrified fence.